Blog Layout

Fastening Matters: The fix is in.

Mar 04, 2020

Fastening Matters: The fix is in.


We see a lot of connections in our work. Not all of these work well, or are what they should have been, particularly existing conditions that never met any kind of engineering or manufacturer specification. While we see some connections that are entirely incorrect, most often these connections are well built poor performers. The person putting them together made common errors, didn’t understand the connection, and/or the oversight was simply deficient. Let’s discuss some common errors, after which we’ll offer some handy tips.


Hanger Nails are Hazards


Most of the time, a contractor installing a timber joist hanger simply fills all the holes with Hanger Nails. Why not? They are for hangers, right? Well yes, and no…


So called “Hanger Nails” are short (1 1/2”) specialty fasteners needed for rare issues and the occasional specified location. They should not be your go to nail. When you install them in a hanger, you get a lower strength than if you’d saved yourself the money and put in a common, and “Hanger Nails” can never be used in a toe nail position, even if through a hanger. Take a look here for more details: https://www.strongtie.com/products/connectors/wood-construction-connectors/technical-notes/fastener-types-and-sizes


Here’s a great post in a home inspector’s blog discussing this in detail: https://www.constructionprotips.com/departments/home-inspector-tales/how-to-correct-improper-joist-hanger-nails/


Screwed Up


We see a lot of hangers with regular screws, drywall screws, or deck screws. There is a reason the typical screw is called a “machine” screw. They aren’t for buildings, and they certainly are not for timber hangers. If you’re connecting wood to wood, the right fastener is a nail. Screws are for decks, or are specialty products that you don’t need to build a normal structure. Once in a while, a specialty timber connector requires screws; take a look at those screws sometime: They are a very special design, with large shanks and not at all like a machine screw. Don’t use them unless you have the need to do so in writing.


Not all bolts are equal


Structural bolts are black, heavy hex, bolts. They have heads far larger than you are used to seeing, or are special fasteners made for wood applications like Coach Bolts and Lag Bolts. Coach and Lags are A307 bolts and nearly always come with a Hot Dip Galvanized coating. They are exclusively for wood, often without any steel involved.


So what do you use when there is steel involved? Sadly, most of the time, the same bolts that go on cars and trailers get used. They aren’t up to the job, and are unsafe. The steel material specs are nearly the same, but everything else is meant for an easily accessible, visually inspectable, short term service use. A bolt in a car or trailer may have to last ten years of constant use. A bolt in a building may have to serve 50, 80, more than 100 years. They are not equal challenges, and material engineers treat them differently.


We very commonly see bolts on site that don’t meet the requirements of the code. This isn’t a minor issue, but it is easily avoided with a little knowledge. If your bolt is “bright”, you’re being dim. We’re unaware of any structural bolt available with the common bright zinc coating. If your bolt has a shimmer, or a head that accepts a wrench and isn’t much thicker than the wrench, it is the wrong bolt until proven otherwise. We’ll put our money where our internet mouths are: Call our team, show us the bolt and the proof, and lunch is on us.


Tips and Tricks:


  • Nail it.

The standard nail in use is the “Common”. You also see a lot of Ardox (twisted along the length). Both of these nails are well made, quality products, mass produced and easily found for good prices. Use them. When in doubt, use a common. If you’re outside, you a Hot Dip Galvanized common nail. You rarely need anything more, and if the nail is longer than the piece into which you’re driving, clinch the nail on the back. Most of the time, it is as simple as using a common nail.


  • Don’t screw up.

Unless you’re looking at a specification that calls for screws, don’t use screws. Even specialty screws can be hard to get right and confusing for all but the most experienced designers and knowledgeable contractors. If you don’t have someone running the numbers, then run from the screws.


  • Bolt with Caution.

When you have steel on your project, have the fabricator apply your nailers (timber bolted to the beam in order to accept nails on site) and prepare you a kit with the fasteners you need. The shop will have easy access to the right heavy hex bolts, and the price you pay will likely be little different than running around for the parts… Besides; We’ve seen shops throw in the bolts for free to attract you back. Let them help you; lean on your fabricator friends.


We’re going to leave you with a little visual hint as to what happens when you get fastenings wrong. This one happens to be what happens when you install an SAE 325 bolt instead of a proper structural heavy hex bolt (ASTM A325).

Bolts that were fastened wrong
By Maurice Quinn 17 Oct, 2023
If you're familiar with steel design, aluminum might just surprise you, and be a welcome technical challenge...
By Maurice Quinn 13 Oct, 2023
Basic, basics, and drainage - Oh my!
By Maurice Quinn 29 Sep, 2023
At 8:30 EDT, we were notified we had a new P.Eng. on staff...
By Maurice Quinn 13 Jul, 2023
Discounted Forensic Engineering for Ottawa...
By Maurice Quinn 22 Jun, 2023
Engineering the past, Engineering of the past, and the passing of a very fine Engineer...
By Maurice Quinn 17 Jun, 2023
Avoid the most common pitfalls...
By Maurice Quinn 23 Mar, 2023
Limits, estimation, sarcasm, and what we do...
By Maurice Quinn 16 Mar, 2023
What happens when your engineer refuses to look at something?
By Maurice Quinn 09 Feb, 2023
When your infrastructure allows you to be anywhere...
By CEL Team 10 Nov, 2022
Fenestration Canada – Field Testing of Fenestrations The presentation we gave at WinDoor 2022 in Montreal contained the core of our philosophy regarding the testing of fenestration products, and I wanted to repeat this here. We take a very simple approach to such work. This can be broken down as follows: 1. We work within the code. 2. We apply the code referenced standards. 3. We run the test in accordance with those standards. 4. We interpret the results. 5. We diagnose and describe issues. 6. We propose possible causal factors. 7. We propose possible solutions. What don’t we do? i. We never test without calibrated, purpose made, equipment. ii. We don’t test assemblies that aren’t ready (very dirty, blocked weeps, etc.). iii. We don’t fail and walk away. IE: We try to actually find the cause, not just state “you fail”. iv. We provide reports that contain clear explanations, detailed descriptions, and attempt to help the overall successful delivery of the project. v. We look for opportunities to work towards real resolutions, and to limit further failure(s). What is the basis of our work? One word: Understanding. We need to understand the design of your building envelope in order to test it correctly. We need to review the details and be involved in the planning of testing. Not every day is a good day to test, not every assembly should be tested in the same way. We want to prepare a test program that is code and contract conformant that maximizes the accuracy of the test. We want fairness and transparency, not speed and a cookie-cutter repeat of previous testing. I’m told that our presentation will be made available online; I look forward to sharing it with you all. In the meantime, please feel confident that when you reach out to our team for Window Installation Testing to ASTM E1105 under CAN/CSA A440 and the supplement, you’re getting a bespoke product that will serve your needs. We want to be your ally; we will make sure that your installers get the best possible support, that the test isn’t simply a “you failed, better luck next time”, that the project doesn’t mire in the weeds for weeks and months as people point fingers. No; we will work for you, and bring a diligent approach and produce success.  Give us a try: We will test for you, we won’t be looking to fail you.
More Posts
Share by: